johnm831's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Salad Fingers Episode 9]

Seriously fucked with my head. Still has the essence of what has made Salad Fingers consistently great over the years. I've basically grown up with Salad Fingers and delighted to see you're still making them. Over time I've grown to like your other animations even more.

[Recycling]

Good Potential

Hey, 3D+Flash GCSE projects ftw! I never posted my GCSE project on NG, mainly cos of filesize, but it makes a much better impression on the mods than print.

If you modelled all that stuff from scratch then that's pretty good. I have to say though, I'd like to see some more experimental stuff from you. If you're given Recycling as a stimulus, it's ok to do like a PSA type thing like this, but personally I'd like to see something a little more abstract. GD is about getting a message across, but it can be a little less blunt than this.

Anyway, don't worry this'll get you good marks as long as you have good coursework to back it up. Basically just reverse engineer the whole thing and show it step by step :P

Good luck with future projects.

alio-big-mac responds:

Thanks,
I did model this from complete scratch and the Moderator has seen the proof, also I put my CW on a cd and its loads n that, took me 4 days to program it, lol.

[ShoBizNewsyNews #38]

nice.

You've done it again Walrus, good job man.

I won't bitch about YAAFM too much, but are you really working on a new one like you said on WDP?

[Burnt Face Man 2]

Amazing

I don't care whether you make more of these or more Salad fingers. Either way, you can really make some brilliant movies. One suggestion though.... (hope this doesn't seem out of order)....the voice (i presume it's your voice) of Salad Fingers is great for that character, but the voice actor is now out of business, because whenever you hear that voice in any of your animations, it really puts me off and I can't get into the movie because it just seems to have the voice of salad fingers in it...that may sound weird. Anyway, keep 'em coming!

[the Metal Rose Dream]

ok

err, FGHFancycat? It's not a gif. Gifs don't have any sounds, and don't get hosted on Newgrounds. Also a gif with as high a res and as long as this would be huge in size.

Anyway, I thought it was okay, but it didn't have a storyline, and for me, if something doesn't have a storyline it has to make up for it by being really funny/weird/violent/original etc

Good job on the graphics anyway.

[YAAFM 9: Michael Moore]

Great as usual

Not sure why people are taking it so seriously. This episode of YAAFM is biased against Michael Moore, yay, but then again F911 was (and Moore admits it) strongly biased against Bush.

About the reviews by bdawkins68 and senjuro... for one thing, senjuro has obviously only even come to this website so he can take cheap shots at American citizens who are trying to enjoy themselves on an entertainment site. I say this as a (sort of) outsider, as a resident of the UK.

If you want a debate about the state of the political world, there's loads of forums where you can do that. This is an entertainment site, and you were meant to be reviewing this animation, not what you think of the US.

Anyway, I think it's great that you've made a new one in the series after a little break. There's just one prob I have with all the animations in this series. At the beginning the lips are synced to the audio really well, but by the end there's a ~1 sec delay between the sound and the video. I dunno why this would happen, as the audio seems to be streaming rather than event, but maybe it's just something wrong at my end.

Anyway, keep making 'em. I'll defintely keep watching.

[Beyond the silence clip 5]

I'm confused

I'm confused...Why the hell doesn't this animation have a higher score?!

[hitchHiker: part Two]

**phew**

Officially the most terrifying thing I've ever seen, more so than any film or any other animation I've come across. You have amazing talent, and I hope you keep creating masterpieces like this.

Thanks
John

[hitchHiker: part One]

Great!

Truly a great animation... I've never been hitch-hiking, but I just came back from a Duke of Edinburgh exhibiton, which for those of you who don't live in UK and have never heard of it is a 20 mile walk with very heavy backpacks and equipment. We didn't get to the campsite so my group of 5 had to sleep in a field, lost, in the middle of nowhere.
So I can kinda empathise with this.

Hizzeh, you are out of order saying this animation has been stolen. You have no evidence whatsoever.... So what if he made it a little while ago. He can still submit it to NG later if he wants. You can't go accusing people of things like that unless you are 100% sure.